So I have been getting a lot of emails asking who Carly is in ShayCarls videos.Carly is ShayCarls sister who lives in his home in Idaho with her son Cooper.I guess she is a single mom and ShayCarl being the awesome person that he is,lets Carly stay in his home!!Thanks for reading guys.Have great day.
There is a guy on youtube by the name ccolonel4 who has posted several comments saying he's Carlie's husband/Cooper's father. Whether that's true or not I don't know but he might actually be. He says he's a baseball player. ccolonel stands for Christian Colonel and his baseball number is 14. On shaycarl's channel there is a video called TRYPTOPHAN CAN CAUSE HUGENESS. There is a guy with Carlie in it. That's him. Look up Christian Colonel in google images, they look like the same person.
omg, how the heck does the person who answered this knows. of course shay is a great guy but maybe shes over a lot because of the son cooper playing with the kids. so whoever that person is who answered this is wrong
no, carly does live in there house because when they were moving, carly was moving her stuff in as well. I'm really curious as to how Cooper came about, Carly is one mysterious lady.
if you have a look at this video that shay posted http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yEbBm8oRHeE the third guy to walk in is christian colonel, if you look at 0.27 carlie says honey to christian. they divorced early 2009 according to what i can find online. Christian accused Carlie of being an alcoholic, when the real reason they had a divorce was because Christan slept with Carlie's best mate and made her pregnant!
I'm really curious about this stuff too but the bottom line is the Shaytards want their privacy and if they find out about sites like these then they are going to stop the vlogs so they can salvage their personal info. I don't think Shay would feel right doing a vlog that is intruding his families privacy, so maybe, for the sake of the vlogs, we should all take a step back.
@ Anonymous (October 31, 2010 10:36 PM) Youtube is public domain! at the end of the day people are inherently nosy,as you can understand that's human nature especially when its comes to 'celebrity'or some what a 'youtube celebrity'.
does cooper live with carlie? he is not always at the house and carlie does not have a bed for him in her room so i was wondering if maybe she does not have custody of him
Carlie's an awesome mom/sister/cheerleading coach. she's defianantly NOT an alcoholic from what i've observed from the SHAYTARDS video. She's awesome with Cooper and Shays kids. She funny, outgoing, responsible and for a plus, SHES FASHIONABLE AND PRETTY! I think Christian made a BIIIIGGGG mistake cheating on Carlie and calling her an alcoholic. She is a perfectly fine pperson. I would love to have her as a friend because her personality is one-in-a million. She's an amazzing peron. Hope oneday she will find someone who deserves her.
cooper is probably spending time with his dad all this time. who knows, maybe they've agreed to have him stay there while she works and saves up money, not everyone knows the real story here, only the family. and you can't just leave cooper home for mommytard to look after as well, it shouldn't be her responsibility but a couple of times, you see that she does watch after him like carlie does for mommytards kids.
Christian did not get anyone else pregnant. Carlie is not an alcoholic. I know both of them well. They are both great people who just weren't meant for each other. I find all the assumptions hilarious.
They're NOT assumptions! Christian is the alcoholic who cheated on Carlie and won't get a real job. He still lives in a dream world..."This time I'll get signed in the big leagues!" Yeah, keep dreaming. He posts crap about Carlie, he is a loser and a drunk.
They both cheated on each other. (Even Carlie's "all knowing Mommy," doesnt know everything about her past) And for Christian to be living in the "dream world?" Wouldnt you keep trying if you were in the minors? He'll give it up eventually. (If it were me I woulda been done long ago...seeing as how he never gets to see his son...priorities are a little mixed up there for sure) For now though, Carlie would rather have Cooper with her anyways so I dont understand why she cares so much that he is gone? They both drank (I know Carlie doesnt drink anymore) and had some crazy nights but neither is an alcoholic. Oh well though right?? They got Cooper out of the whole mess. Pretty sure they will both look back on this nonsense someday and realize that was the only thing that mattered.
what is everyones obsession with carlie having nights out or having drinks? she is a young woman. Geez, us young moms are allowed a life too you know! Doesn't mean we're alcoholics.
Cooper stays with Christian in Idaho while Carlie is in CA. And Carlie is not an alcoholic. She doesn't talk about it so she obviously doesn't want everyone to know every detail about her life. I'm sure that Christian and Carlie do what is best for Cooper.
Hey guys, this is Shay. I would appreciate it if you guys focus on my family instead of Carlie's. It's not fair that she's stealing all my thunder. Rumble, rumble.
Thanks for the info on Carly,she is so hawt(hot).
ReplyDeleteLove the blog!
ReplyDeletedo you know who old she is?
ReplyDeleteI would say that she is around 27.What is your guess?
ReplyDeleteShe is 21 as of June 8, 2010
ReplyDeletenot true I grew up 2 houses down try 23 mabey 24 as of her birthday in 2010
Deleteshe just turned 25 about a month ago
DeleteIn the video you are referring to,Shaycarl say's that he is joking and she is really older then 21.Don't get me wrong she looks really young.
ReplyDeletewho is her son's father, was he her boyfriend.
ReplyDeleteDoes cooper's father see him?
There is a guy on youtube by the name ccolonel4 who has posted several comments saying he's Carlie's husband/Cooper's father. Whether that's true or not I don't know but he might actually be. He says he's a baseball player. ccolonel stands for Christian Colonel and his baseball number is 14. On shaycarl's channel there is a video called TRYPTOPHAN CAN CAUSE HUGENESS. There is a guy with Carlie in it. That's him. Look up Christian Colonel in google images, they look like the same person.
ReplyDeletesorry that's ccolonel14
ReplyDeletei bet she is living there to help keep an eye on all the kids
ReplyDeleteyep, christian colonel is coopers daddy
ReplyDeleteHer name is spelled Carlie not Carly.... her youtube channel is CarlieStyle
ReplyDeleteomg, how the heck does the person who answered this knows. of course shay is a great guy but maybe shes over a lot because of the son cooper playing with the kids. so whoever that person is who answered this is wrong
ReplyDeleteno, carly does live in there house because when they were moving, carly was moving her stuff in as well.
ReplyDeleteI'm really curious as to how Cooper came about, Carly is one mysterious lady.
She's 23 now!!
ReplyDeleteCheck the info in the pants bar for the vid from last year
http://www.youtube.com/user/SHAYTARDS#p/search/8/gUcj9jlKCiw
If shay's last name is carl, and carlie is his sister, would her real name be carlie carl LOL?
ReplyDeletehaha their last name is not carl its butler
ReplyDeleteNo, Because shay's dads name is carl so carl is shay's middle name
ReplyDeleteCarlie listed her name at ISU as Carlie Butler-Colonel at one point. She also put her engagement ring for sale online last year.
ReplyDeleteHow do you know that she put her engagement ring online for sale? When did she marry that Christian colonel guy anyway?
ReplyDeleteHow do you know?
ReplyDeletehttp://www.idahostatejournal.com/sports/local/article_7176e408-da16-11de-9791-001cc4c002e0.html
ReplyDeleteyeah, he is Coopers father :)
her myspace says she's 18....
ReplyDeletehttp://www.idahostatejournal.com/sports/local/article_7176e408-da16-11de-9791-001cc4c002e0.html
ReplyDeleteCheck it! He is coopers dad
if you have a look at this video that shay posted http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yEbBm8oRHeE
ReplyDeletethe third guy to walk in is christian colonel, if you look at 0.27 carlie says honey to christian. they divorced early 2009 according to what i can find online. Christian accused Carlie of being an alcoholic, when the real reason they had a divorce was because Christan slept with Carlie's best mate and made her pregnant!
check out this photo of Christian and Coopertard!
http://www.idahostatejournal.com/sports/local/article_7176e408-da16-11de-9791-001cc4c002e0.html
I'm really curious about this stuff too but the bottom line is the Shaytards want their privacy and if they find out about sites like these then they are going to stop the vlogs so they can salvage their personal info. I don't think Shay would feel right doing a vlog that is intruding his families privacy, so maybe, for the sake of the vlogs, we should all take a step back.
ReplyDeletewhat is carlie's myspace?
ReplyDeletecoopers dad is Christian Colonel. i just saw a article on it with them together
ReplyDeletewait who is that teenager? is he their brother as well?
ReplyDelete@ Anonymous (October 31, 2010 10:36 PM)
ReplyDeleteYoutube is public domain! at the end of the day people are inherently nosy,as you can understand that's human nature especially when its comes to 'celebrity'or some what a 'youtube celebrity'.
im guessing she was born after shay and casey so probably around 1985 considering she was apparently a boise state cheereleader in 2006.
ReplyDeletedoes cooper live with carlie? he is not always at the house and carlie does not have a bed for him in her room so i was wondering if maybe she does not have custody of him
ReplyDeletewow.....if u were such a huge shaytards fan you would probably know that she speels her name Carlie
ReplyDelete'speels' is spelled incorrectly. its spells.
ReplyDeleteCarlie's an awesome mom/sister/cheerleading coach.
ReplyDeleteshe's defianantly NOT an alcoholic from what i've observed from the SHAYTARDS video. She's awesome with Cooper and Shays kids. She funny, outgoing, responsible and for a plus, SHES FASHIONABLE AND PRETTY!
I think Christian made a BIIIIGGGG mistake cheating on Carlie and calling her an alcoholic. She is a perfectly fine pperson. I would love to have her as a friend because her personality is one-in-a million. She's an amazzing peron.
Hope oneday she will find someone who deserves her.
cooper is probably spending time with his dad all this time. who knows, maybe they've agreed to have him stay there while she works and saves up money, not everyone knows the real story here, only the family. and you can't just leave cooper home for mommytard to look after as well, it shouldn't be her responsibility but a couple of times, you see that she does watch after him like carlie does for mommytards kids.
ReplyDeletehere is a picture of cooper and his dad at the batting cages! ^_^
ReplyDeletehttp://www.idahostatejournal.com/sports/local/article_7176e408-da16-11de-9791-001cc4c002e0.html?mode=image&photo=1
Christian did not get anyone else pregnant. Carlie is not an alcoholic. I know both of them well. They are both great people who just weren't meant for each other. I find all the assumptions hilarious.
ReplyDeleteThey're NOT assumptions! Christian is the alcoholic who cheated on Carlie and won't get a real job. He still lives in a dream world..."This time I'll get signed in the big leagues!" Yeah, keep dreaming. He posts crap about Carlie, he is a loser and a drunk.
ReplyDeleteThey both cheated on each other. (Even Carlie's "all knowing Mommy," doesnt know everything about her past) And for Christian to be living in the "dream world?" Wouldnt you keep trying if you were in the minors? He'll give it up eventually. (If it were me I woulda been done long ago...seeing as how he never gets to see his son...priorities are a little mixed up there for sure) For now though, Carlie would rather have Cooper with her anyways so I dont understand why she cares so much that he is gone? They both drank (I know Carlie doesnt drink anymore) and had some crazy nights but neither is an alcoholic. Oh well though right?? They got Cooper out of the whole mess. Pretty sure they will both look back on this nonsense someday and realize that was the only thing that mattered.
ReplyDeletep.s. I love the Shaytards :)
Carlie is so pretty and the Shaytards ROCK!
ReplyDeleteCarlie never cheated on Christian. She still drinks a lot. Christian doesn't play baseball anymore. There are the real facts.
ReplyDeleteyou guys are freaks
ReplyDeletewhat is everyones obsession with carlie having nights out or having drinks? she is a young woman. Geez, us young moms are allowed a life too you know! Doesn't mean we're alcoholics.
ReplyDeleteshay lived with carlie not the other way round :)
ReplyDeleteCooper stays with Christian in Idaho while Carlie is in CA. And Carlie is not an alcoholic. She doesn't talk about it so she obviously doesn't want everyone to know every detail about her life. I'm sure that Christian and Carlie do what is best for Cooper.
ReplyDeleteHey guys, this is Shay. I would appreciate it if you guys focus on my family instead of Carlie's. It's not fair that she's stealing all my thunder. Rumble, rumble.
ReplyDeleteSorry, but I really don't think you're actually Shay. You would have a name or URL! Correct me if I'm wrong.
Delete